Anna's Cure Thread - part 2 | Arthritis Information

Share
 

I started to post this under Anna's thread - until I stumbled upon a related article.   I was going to joke around about my posts about needing a new class of antibiotics so we got our cure. 
 
Hey - by accident I found it!
 
Look back over page 2 about the 'new class' of antibiotics.
 
Then look at this study - be fair now - look at page 2 first.  ;-)
 
(inserting pg 2 here)   
http://www.arthritisinsight.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=15342&PN=2
 
Then look how this study is being spun.
 
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/04/080401095233.htm
 
So, I traced the study back to the magazine listed.
 
http://aac.asm.org/cgi/gca?sendit=Get+All+Checked+Abstract%28s%29&SEARCHID=1&TITLEABSTRACT=lyme&FIRSTINDEX=0&hits=10&RESULTFORMAT=&gca=aac%3BAAC.01050-07v1
 
Then to PubMed.
 
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12404158?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DiscoveryPanel.Pubmed_Discovery_RA&linkpos=1
 
Then to a related TNF article because I just thought it would say it works for it also as they all seem to.  But it didn't.
 
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17436229?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DiscoveryPanel.Pubmed_Discovery_RA&linkpos=3
 
We need to be very sure we don't have Lyme.
 
Pip
P.S.  If the links don't work, delete any extra spaces and try again.
 
Edited to link to Anna's page 2 thread.
Pip!2008-04-17 17:13:57I think it would be good practice to test for Lyme's disease if anti tnf's don't work.  If continued joint pain, etc.  Sounds like it would save the patient money, the insurance company money with less stress and sometimes harmful incidents to the patient.  I would think the insurance co. would rather pay for a Lyme test and antibiotics  than years of dmards and anti tnfs.  LindyOk.. Correct me if I'm making incorrect assumptions.
 
 RA is caused by Lyme... infested and embedded...
 
(which could easily answer the 10% who are disease free after the AP therapy)
 
IF RA is caused by Lyme...
 
then there should be a demographic showing the prevalent areas of lyme/RA, no?
 
I'm trying to understand your points here.. and I have some questions that are nagging bout the articles..
 
 
ETA:  I was tested twice for Lymes
 
 
 
babs102008-04-17 18:20:26

My bad.  This just really freaked me out and I didn't explain myself.   Trying again. 

First issue up for discussion is how did those studies, which read the opposite of what the Science Daily article said, get spun like that? 
 
This is the AF thread where I'd read the original - and you can see how freaked I was before I posted here. 
 
http://ww2.arthritis.org/communitiesnew/forum/replymsg.aspx?msgid=237685&status=none&msggroupid=22&view=yes
 
LinB -
 
What this is saying is that TNF's can activate Lyme.  And Lyme is one hard to kill microbe.  This is part of the ongoing "Lyme Wars" because traditional research is saying 2 - 3 weeks of antibiotics is enough to kill them.  This shows conclusively that its not.  It's also showing that you can have Lyme and transmit it while showing negative.
 
Couple that with the problems of conventional testing that exists.  Even the CDC and the Elisa and the Western Blot is 'flawed'.  The only somewhat reliable test out there is the IgeneX - but like our tests for RF or CRP - it's not like they are 'foolproof'. 
 
And yes, you would think the Insurance Companies would prefer that, wouldn't you.  Except, like us, they rely on those same studies our docs rely on.  See the Merck posts from yesterday?  I'm amazed that I'm beginning to believe our only hope for a cure is from the money hungry insurance companies. 
 
Babs -
 
Lyme has RA-like symptoms. 
 
Yes, it could account for the 10% of those disease free after AP (thanks for catching that).  However - APer's tend to be a bit dogmatic and once you buy into the whole AP thing, you tend to get the IgeneX test.  Not all of us have Lyme and some of us have been medicine free without being exposed to Lyme.  I intend to be in that group even tho I tested negative on the Igenex test.
 
Yes, I've seen posts of Lyme areas.  Mostly rural areas in the NW part of the country.  Amy Tan got it in N. Cal, I think.  They now know chipmunks can carry the fleas too.  It's been reported all over the world. 
 
The part that freaked me out was the fact that suppressing the immune system could reactivate the bugger.  That would/could/lead to one hard to kill microbe and possibly a more severe form of RA than would be possible without the TNF.
 
Please, I really like you guys.  Just think about getting tested.  If you're a hiker, play with animals, go camping...whatever.  Just be sure, please.
 
You might be able to argue your doc into getting the test - I wasn't - but - if you're on TNF's that might motivate them.
 
Pip

Pip, it doesn't matter where the cure comes from.  Like many of us have said, it could be a simple cure and inexpensive, but the road to the cure is very expensive. 

I lived in No. Calif. for 20 years, hiked and camped all my life, had pets all my life and lived in the country for 20 years.  I guess I should seriously think about getting tested.  I've thought about it in the past but nothing really prompted me to get tested till I read that last study.  Will talk to my RD about it at next appt. and I think insist on being tested.  Lindy
Thanks sweetie - let us know what you find out. 
 
Again, not trying to freak anybody out (we all know I see microbes EVERYWHERE).  Just, I'd rather people were safe than sorry.
 
Hugs,
 
Pip
Thanks for the synopsis. I'm so darn busy these days I haven't been able to keep up on reading about new developments, so it's great to at least get an idea and a bookmark for future reference!gotcha Pip.. I totally get the RA/Lyme similarities....Thanks for explaining it.  Any dr who would deny us a Igenex test is being ridiculous.  RA treatments are very expensive and if discovery by a mere blood test of Lyme would prevent the need... Wouldnt' they all want to do that??From the Science Daily article (please note this is full spin mode):

"When the antibiotic treatments were completed, DNA analysis showed that small numbers of the Lyme disease-causing bacteria remained in the tissues of the antibiotic-treated mice. Ticks allowed to feed on these infected mice were also able to acquire and transmit the infectious bacteria. Curiously, despite the apparent viability of the bacteria, they could not be detected by standard laboratory cultures.

The findings support the theory that the bacteria remain viable and that some bacteria evade antibiotic treatment by taking refuge in collagen-rich tissues, skin, ligaments and tendons."


This study shows that Lyme bacteria is not detected by standard testing.  This study shows that current antibiotics do not completely wipe out the infectious bacteria and it remains in you (so maybe your body is not attacking itself, right?).  This study shows that mice with this condition can still spread disease.

You know, this isn't the first time it's crossed my mind that maybe all arthritis is Lyme's. Especially since it's been discovered that Lyme's disease can be transmitted by fleas and mosquitoes, and not just ticks as previously thought.

That would also explain the large sacle push by certain interests to deny the existance of lymes.

I'm really wanting to see that new documentary "Under Our Skin:the Untold Story of Lymes"
http://www.openeyepictures.com/underourskin/Lyme was discovered when a bunch of moms called the CDC because all their kids were being dx'd with JRA.  GO MOMS!!!!!! Well, it's odd, isn't it, that Lyme's can be so recognised as an infectious disease but RA can't, even though the symptoms are sometimes almost indistinguishable.

I have a good friend with Lymes who had multiple diagnosis (diagnosii?) before Lyme's, including MS. I hooked her up with a doctor I knew about from the Road Back. He has dozens of people's testimonies on RateMDs who say he literally saved their lives, and yet his license is being revoked because of how he treats Lyme's patients with long term antibiotics. It's crazy. And heartbreaking.

It just doesn't make any sense.

Those doctors that are denying entrenched Lyme's disease exists all have very close ties to pharmaceutical companies, who have powerful lobbyists at the federal level. It's just so mind-bogglingly evil. Don't they know that?
Suzanne2009-03-14 18:37:31Well, you don't have to look into it for too long or too deep to find dozens of stories like that.

To me that's a sign there's something valuable hidden at the end of the Lyme's rainbow.Pip, Fantastic info. Exactly what I was looking for..ThanksThanks 6t5
 
GoGo - that doc looks like a winner to me.  I'm betting it's up for an Oscar doc. 
 
Also, it can't be just Lymes - maybe only the increase in numbers since it was 'discovered'.  RA's been around for 100K years in the New World - but only in England since the late 1600's I believe,  It's something we sent back to them.  So, obviously, it's different microbes.  I'm thinking since Europe has more AS - m. fermantens (spelling) is the microbe inplicated in that.  It must have more affinity for the CNS than Lyme/RA has for the joints. 
 
What do you think?
 
Pip
hi all i just wonderd what is lymes  i have not heard of it..
Boney

Lyme is an infection from a tick bite (usually) that can present like RA or the other auto-immune diseases.  It is curable by antibiotics - but not just 2 or 3 weeks.  The tests for it are junk so you have to go to a specialized lab.  Mainstream medicine is saying we're all 'auto-immune' yet more and more is proving to be 'infection.'

If you have Lyme - you have hope of a eventual cure.  Get 'really' tested to be sure.  And apparently, we should not be on TNF's if we have Lyme.
 
Pip
Wait a minute, calm down.

Here is a map showing where lyme is, most states don't have it.

http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/lyme/riskmap.htm

It is a completely different disease from RA.Anna -
 
From Web MD -
 
The number of reported cases of Lyme disease, as well as the number of geographic areas in which it is found, has been increasing. Lyme disease has been reported in nearly all states in this country, although most cases are concentrated in the coastal northeast, Mid-Atlantic States, Wisconsin and Minnesota, and northern California. Lyme disease is also found in large areas of Asia and Europe. Recent reports suggest that it is present in South America, too.
 
This is info straight CDC is great on Lyme textbook info - showing your message was 'old info' - not the stuff we're talking about here.  Again, there's enough in here to scare many of us...even tho the CDC admits the tests are flawed etc. and the new study shows people are infected and can reinfect others etc...
 
http://www.textbookofbacteriology.net/Lyme.html
 
Lyme may be misdiagnosed as RA.  For those that have been misdiagnosed, TNF inhibitors are not a good idea.  I'd think you'd want to have people be tested to protect them.
 
BTW - aren't you in the NE somewhere?  Have you had the Igenex test?
 
Pip
No need to keep scaring people. Lyme ticks need temperate climate, though the African lice sounds scary.

Here is a world map.

http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/lyme/who_cc/index.htm   


Yeah, Pip, stop scaring people with your, you know, reality and everything.

Seriously, though, I don't think giving people a heads up on what might be the source of their health woes is ever a bad thing, Anna. But as someone who doesn't like being challenged, I'm guessing you won't be lining up to see Under Our Skin: the Untold Story of Lyme Disease, an infectious new film about microbes, money and medicine. But that doesn't mean the rest of us can't have a discussion about it.

The fact is no one knows how widespread Lyme Disease is, and some doctors now believe that Lyme can be spread by mosquitoes and fleas as well as ticks.

What's interesting about Lyme is that it's a type of arthritis known to be caused by infection.

Some Lymies think its an STD too.  Who know?  All I do know is we need to be sure is what is going on in our bodies.  It's the only way we can heal. 
 
The movie premiers at Tribeca, right?  That's pretty prestigious.  I wonder why they didn't wait for Sundance.  More exposure there.
 
Pip
I live in a Lyme endemic area. I truly beleive it is an Epidemic that is spreding. Perhaps it's always been around. Remember that for years many thought it was JRA or RA. On Long Island NY they had something called Long Island Knee. They thought it was a form of RA. The Deer Tick can carry all kinds of other transmitable diseases. The testing leaves a lot to be desired. If your body does not respond with an anti-body after the bite your test will be Negative. Remember the test is not to see if you have Lyme but to see if your body is reacting to the bite. There are so many False Negatives that even the CDC says diagnosis is based on Synptoms. The CDC requirements for a Positive test are from 1993, Crazy !!!. For example, if you get a Western Blot test, the results are shown as " bands " There are some very specific bands that can only be form a Lyme tick. The CDC requires that you need 5 of these bands to be positive. So you could have 4 and the test will say Negative. Most DR's don't know anything about Lyme. They will look no further into Lyme. Labs like Quest and Lab Corp are not noted for their Lyme testing. Here is another example of how the CDC gets it wrong. Say you have a test and have 4 bands show. The fifth band is band 31, Band 31 is a very Lyme specific band. They will not include it since a few years back they actually made the Lymerix vaccine ( it's been taken off the market ) from it. They will not include it since they fear someone may have taken the vaccine years ago. So 4 bands that are Lyme specific and band 31 and your DR gets a NEGATIVE result mailed to him. Some Labs actually list ALL the bands when you get the test back and a good DR can make a jugement form it. Igenix in California is one.MDL another. Any way you look at it it's scary. This week in my local paper there was an article about how Lyme can Live on even after treatment. People have died from it. If your DR says OK we will do an Elisa test you can agree but also get a Western Blot test done. Oh and half the people bitten never get the Bulls Eye rash Dr's speak of. I have seen how debilitating this can be first hand. You are the second person that's posted in the last week about MDL.  Can you send me a link for my files?  I swear I thought they went out of business.  Maybe that was Great Smokies Lab or something like that. 
 
And thank you for the info on which bands are more important.  If you have any info on that I'd like to research it.  Also, I need to pull my IgeneX test.  I'm wondering which bands were positive.  My AP doc is versed in Lyme and he said I didn't have it.  But, I'd like to be 'triple sure'.
 
Pip
Pip, Mdlab.com.....Please post your Igenix results. Also ck out Lymenet.org for info on tests etc...6t5 -
 
I just found the last of all my paperwork.  I'm intending on organizing it and will post when I find it.  The pile is over 6 inches deep and I was only diagnosed 2 years ago!
 
 
Thanks,
 
Pip
OK Pip Interested in seeing what bands showed upSo am I.
 
Pip
Thanks for the GREAT info, 6T5.

Got this in my email box:

BRINGING LYME TO THE LIMELIGHT!

The Tribeca Film Festival is honoring UNDER OUR SKIN and the Lyme disease issue by hosting a special film presentation and "Behind the Screens" panel discussion with festival films representing "truth, clarity and responsibility." Only three films from the festival were chosen for this high-visibility event. UNDER OUR SKIN is one of these three films, and the only documentary.

Best-selling author Amy Tan will be part of the panel discussion, as well as the film's director Andy Abrahams Wilson and Lyme specialist Dr. Richard Horowitz. The discussion will be moderated by NBC Chief Health and Medical Correspondent Robert Bazell.

Sunday, April 27, 6:30PM
Directors Guild of America (DGA) Theater
110 West 57th Street (Between 6th & 7th Avenue)
New York City

GoGo - if you hear of something like that on the west coast - let me know and I'll see if I can find a friend of a friend who can get me in.

Pip
I will. This just started screening so it hasn't made the rounds yet.It is a terrible disease, an epidemic but only it certain areas, I too like in an area where it is serious. The doctors all know and test you 10 different ways, repeatedly.

But if you live in 80% of the US, you have no problems. Look at the map.

http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/lyme/riskmap.htm

Can't wait to see the movie.Anna/Birdgirl -
 
It's no longer just 20%.  It's in all but 2 states, I think, that was in the CDC post.  It's in the UK.  It's in SA.  It's everywhere. 
 
The Great U doesn't know.  I begged them to do the Igenex test and was seen by one of the top 2 infectious disease MD's there.  He had no idea what I was talking about.  Mind you, this was in 2006.  We even offered to pay for it ourselves and they still refused.
 
If you weren't tested by IgeneX or MDlabs - please reconsider.
 
Pip

Pip, Did you find the Lyme tests ??

No - sorry - but I do now have staging area for all my medical info!  I'm finding notes to myself, to the docs, lab work mixed in the tax info.  That 6 month Armour Thyroid/aspirin fiasco really set me back on just living life (or at least filing it right).  Now I know why I couldn't find anything at the end - I was putting things in the wrong places.  So, now I'm rebuilding my life and my filing system- which is apparently much more complicated when you 'mis-filed' it. 
 
I have some things in my life that kind of went to 'red alert' status.  I'm dealing with that now (like I need to go get that MRI I keep putting off) and stuff with my daughter and the accident.  As soon as I get that back on track, I'm off to organize my files. 
 
Don't worry - you're gonna be the first person I contact when I find it.  You know the most.
 
Pip
P.S.  Do you think Plaindromic is usually Lyme?  My hope is leaning that way.
 
Pip
Pip, Were your knees the first to bother you??Here is an interesting editorial about lyme.

http://www.prevention.com/cda/expertblog/health/health.experts?plckController=Blog&plckBlogPage=BlogViewPost&newspaperUserId=d8aaf1b5-0074-4419-8bbf-c8c6b34222ad&plckPostId=Blog%3ad8aaf1b5-0074-4419-8bbf-c8c6b34222adPost%3a9ccdea5e-f2d4-4a25-8f02-218a9ad61e4b&plckScript=blogScript&plckElementId=blogDest
Bird Girl. Link won't work
Copyright ArthritisInsight.com