a few steps forward... then back again (long) | Arthritis Information

Share
 

(warning could be TMI)

 
Seems to be the way things go around here isn't it?  Take a couple steps forward only to go backward again shortly after.
 
Started my enbrel two weeks ago... it was great!!  Major improvement first day.  Then I got an infection in my eye due to the plugs the opthamologist inserted coming loose and scratching things  ... on with antibiotics for that... no enbrel for 10 extra days.
 
I also saw my GYN and she gave me estradiol pills for insertion to help w/ my enlarged menopausal uterus, slight incontinence when standing up and burning and thinning of walls.  Well, I started using them the first night.. and while it helped with some of my feminine issues..  I was surprised to feel a TON better.  Energy!!! wooo hooo! and just a great general sense of well-being.  Mood lifted and happier than I have been.  Surprising right, in light of not being able to do my enbrel protocol and being concerned with halting that!!
 
So, I began to do some research...
 
Let me preface this with my realization that many of us are very different in how the disease affects us and our stages of life.  Adding also my history of having JRA (prepubescent) and then not having any major difficulties w/ RA (except one small flare after 3rd child was born) til menopause....  I am putting this out there knowing full well that we have many women in prime years of life who are still of child bearing years and there are men involved with this RA as well.  And, adding that my gyn said, rather off=handed, that this little estradiol pill inserted could help with  my RA issues... I thought nothing of it.
 
so, I went to my friend, google and asked about estrogen and RA.  this is what he said (exerpted but links included)


http://arthritis-research.com/content/5/4/R202

conclusion:
Quote:
In summary, we found in this controlled clinical trial that the increase of E2 levels in serum was highly correlated with improved BMD. We have tried to elucidate possible ways, in the network of proinflammatory cytokines and IGF-1, by which HRT exerts its effects on the skeleton in long-lasting active RA. We found that HRT reduces serum levels of sIL-6R, whereas IGF-1 levels were observed to be increased. Both of these results – the effects on the IL-6/ sIL-6R pathway and on IGF-1 in the endocrine system – may be involved in the mechanisms mediating the beneficial effects of HRT. There is a need for larger, controlled, long-term studies of combined treatment in RA – estrogen plus progestogen, and estrogen alone – to support our results and to investigate the effects of the various hormones.





http://ra.com/ra/rastore/cgi-bin/PrintFriendly_Cat_200635_NavRoot_303_ProdID_200800.htm

Quote:
Hormonal Factors: A third theory is that RA may be affected by hormones. Researchers have found that hormones, like estrogen and progesterone, increase during pregnancy but decrease afterward. This may explain why onset of RA often occurs following child birth or why women with RA who become pregnant often experience significant symptom improvement during pregnancy but have flare ups of RA once they have given birth.


http://www.pueblo.gsa.gov/cic_text/health/rheumatoid/current.html

Quote:

Scientists are studying the complex relationships among the hormonal, nervous, and immune systems in rheumatoid arthritis. For example, they are exploring whether and how the normal changes in the levels of steroid hormones (such as estrogen and testosterone) during a person’s lifetime may be related to the development, improvement, or flares of the disease. Scientists are also looking at how these systems interact with environmental and genetic factors. Results from these studies may suggest new treatment strategies.

Researchers are exploring why so many more women than men develop rheumatoid arthritis. In hopes of finding clues, they are studying female and male hormones and other elements that differ between women and men, such as possible differences in their immune responses.

To find clues to new treatments, researchers are examining why rheumatoid arthritis often improves during pregnancy. Results of one study suggest that the explanation may be related to differences in certain special proteins between a mother and her unborn child. These proteins help the immune system distinguish between the body’s own cells and foreign cells. Such differences, the scientists speculate, may change the activity of the mother’s immune system during pregnancy.


http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/459098
Quote:


Estrogen deficiency is known to increase bone remodeling and resorption, which subsequently leads to an increased risk of osteoporosis. Hormone replacement therapy (HRT) is known to restore this imbalance. Receptors for the sex steroids estrogen, androgen, and progesterone have been shown to be expressed in the osteoblasts and osteoclasts.[2] Estrogen, besides having direct effects on bone cells, also acts indirectly, by modulating the production of osteoclast-stimulating and -inhibiting factors by paracrine substances from bone marrow cells and by the osteoblasts.[2] Estrogen also influences the skeleton through the endocrine system, increasing the production of insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1), which has anabolic effects on bone.[3,4]

The effects of sex hormones on rheumatic diseases are controversial. Some data suggest that estrogens and HRT may be beneficial in RA,[5-7] whereas other findings did not show amelioration of disease activity by HRT.[8] The peak incidence of RA in women coincides with the perimenopausal age, suggesting a connection with hormonal alterations.[9] Furthermore, type-II-collagen-induced arthritis in female mice is exacerbated by ovariectomy and is ameliorated by subsequent treatment with estradiol (E2).[10] In a recent trial exploring the effects of HRT in RA, we found ameliorating effects on clinical measures of disease activity and inflammation, improved bone mineral density (BMD), and also results pointing towards retardation of joint damage.[11]

The aim of this study was to assess the effects of HRT on serum levels of the osteoclast-stimulating cytokines, tumor necrosis factor (TNF-), IL-I, IL-6, on their modifiers IL-1-receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra

 
I am in no way insinuating that this is a revelation to many of you... but it really was to me though I always had an odd thought here and there about the timing of MY RA issues. 
 
I am not sure that I would even weigh the risks of doing a full HRT protocol with the cancer potential...but that this little teeny pill is helping me and is safer than oral HRT.... and I wanted anyone else who may have the same age issues as myself to have information that may help them make a choice for additional RX. 
 
(Possible coincidence but thought to put this out there too.. On Monday, the day I first took the estradiol, my Requip stopped working as efficiently.  I am going to have to call the neuro to increase dosage.  Relative?  I don't know.)
hi babs i allways wonderd about the pregnancy link myself..
but as i cant get pregnant no way to find out.. thanks, BoneyThanks for this post.
My husband and I have had conversations about certain
hormones being a link to Ra . And how lots of ladies go
through a remission during pregnancy or have a major
flare during menstral . Or feeling the best during a
menstral .
Hormones ... I am glad that it is being studied.

Copyright ArthritisInsight.com