answer from disability | Arthritis Information

Share
 

I received my answer from disabilty. While they feel I am disabled and cant do my job of 14 years, they feel I am not disabled enough. At least they said I am disabled. Since my ra is most severe in my hands, wrists, and elbows I wonder what job they think I can do. any thoughts or advice would be welcome.

if you disagree with the decsion the only thing to do is to appeal.  If you haven't already consider getting a lawyer or advocate at this point.  Review ALL of your medical records to insure that they support everything you told social security.I would agree with Buckeye in that you should appeal. You may well need a lawyer to help you. Best of luck to you Get a disability attorney.  They all aren't the same, there are good ones and bad ones.  Do some research.  I used one of the national disability attorneys and they were excellent.  Lindydon't give up.. you can't do your job.. you can't work.........
 
good luck!!
I'm in agreement w/all the other posters:  I'd heard that it's most unusual to get approved the 1st time around, so it's very wise to appeal.  In fact, here in NJ, I believe that you MUST have an attorney if you chose to appeal:  it cannot be done on your own.  After reviewing my case, my lawyer worked on a contingency basis, and his fee was pre-determined by the government - 33% of your $ benefits, retroactive from the date you first applied to the date you are finally approved, if I remember correctly.  (Not sure re the particulars, as I've been on disability for 10 years now........I'm sure there are other, wiser folks on these great boards that will point you in right direction!)   Stay strong, and best of luck to you!  Let us know how you make out?
Dogmom

K...  I am in that disability process right now too---in US..(it's probably different elsewhere).

I was told the same thing! I'm still going through this myself. If this was your first denial, don't panic. It turns out they deny 85-90% of applicants at that stage, probably a sneaky trick to weed out people who give up easy or are too overwhelmed to try.
 
This may be longwinded, but worth your attention if you don't know what to expect.
Here's what I've gone through so far:
 
--1st application... I had to go for an in-person meeting at local SSA office.
           .... a packet of papers for more info came in mail, I filled out & mailed
           .... I waited waited waited
           .... I was denied...."although we agree.... we don't feel it should keep you from
                working...we agree you cannot do your regular job, but you can do others" 
--2nd step............ I hand delivered (for stamped date) a request for Reconsideration
            .... they agreed to investigate further, needed more papers             
            .... I got a Disability Lawyer in case I were to get denied again
            .... I waited waited waited
            .... I was denied again...didn't even consider some of my most major problems!
--3rd step............. My lawyer helped me to formally request a Hearing before a Judge
            .... next, he is going to request it be expedited due to financial hardship
                 (we need income by me to pay rent, once we lose our home)
             .... I'm again, waiting waiting waiting
             .... I'll be given a date
             .... lawyer & I will meet so I can explain everything about me to him
             .... he & I will go meet with the judge... in person
                  (at a table in conference room -not big trial courtroom... still scary to me!)  
 
So that's as far as I know for now. I think there are 2 more steps to try, but I can't imagine higher courts cancelling a judge's decision.
They will look at me with all my invisible problems and compare me to someone paralyzed, on a ventilator, unable to speak, with 24hr nursing care!... It's so darn frustrating! Besides RA, I also struggle with UC and have unexpected,hours-long painful diarrhea episodes 1-4days per week ....on any day, any time.  So, I'd really like to see how their employer (fed gov) would view them if they repeatedly either couldn't show up on time, had to call-in sick at last minute, or during their day at work, suddenly had to leave! and that's not even addressing my RA challenges... can't type long, sit long, lift or carry much, stand long, walk long-or quickly, +when needing a cane, bad shoulder can't lift or carry more than papers.  And try "rushing" to bathroom with bad hips&feet and then, pulling pants down..then up...then down.. with painful fingers & shoulder! And those don't even describe the awful RA fatigue with brain shut-down I get every afternoon, so even if I do find a flexible job, it could only be 3-4hrs in mornings. Who is going to hire me with all that going on? I have tried other jobs, even at-home, on phone, but was unable to do them or the training to prepare to do them. If it were them, they would be either not hired, or fired... I've experienced both.  
 
To tell you the truth, I'm hoping when I meet with the judge, I am having a bad day all around so maybe it shows a little! Well, except that I need to actually appear before the judge, so I'd better not have diarrhea (it doesn't matter what I eat and stress never causes it) and I'd better not be so fatigued I'm getting brain fog since I need to think and speak sensibly to get my situation explained well.
 
Sorry for my own ranting.  I totally get your frustrations. Maybe you already know the steps I listed above, but just in case you didn't, I hope they help you plan what's next.
 
Now that you have been denied once, immediately bring in (for stamped date) your request for Reconsideration and then contact a lawyer who specializes in disability. 
 
I have no money to pay mine, which is ok because he will get his fee (20% or ,000-whichever is less -from my big retroactive check) but only if he helps me to get approved for disability... so besides his caring about helping me, there's money motivation too!) I chose him because he was at a conference for colitis patients so really understands how that disease alone is so debilitating. And I have RA too which affects me every single day.   
                         
K..Don't give up... go to next step immediately. They deal with requests in chronological order of receiving them. Then while you are waiting waiting, get a lawyer on your side.
 
Good luck to both of us... please keep me posted. Don't be discouraged by my story.
You may have worse RA symptoms than me and have no more denials.
 
CathyMarie
Cathy is right on.  I went through all that trying to get my disability.  You should get a disability lawyer... the way the system is set up, you are almost 100% guaranteed denial if you don't have one.  It shouldn't be this way - we need the money more than the lawyer - but it is this way. 

Also, a letter from your RD predicting how much work you may miss due to flares, pain, illness due a lowered immune system, any side effects of the drugs (nausea) and so on helps too.

Don't be discouraged, fight!  It took me almost 2 years to get mine, tiny as it is, but worth it!
thank you everyone for the advise. I will keep you postedHope your next try is more successful! KK~ I don't understand this.  Who, exactly, has decided that you are "not disabled enough"?  Are "they" doctors?  Do "they" know you?  Have "they" consulted with your physician and if yes, on what grounds did they deem his evaluation of you to be untrustworthy?   Do you suffer from depression, as this alone would get you a disability pension in Australia and also alcoholism, hope you don't have either but depression is common with chronic illness.  Regards Janie. Linda, read my post above, I'm in the same boat as K. 
My RD says she thinks it's decided by a heartless computer.
 
I tend to agree. One of the things said to me on my first denial was "we think you can move your arms and legs in a satisfactory manner and you can walk".  I guess they want me to be in a coma or totally paralyzed-ventilator dependent-unable to talk! oh yeah, they also claimed that "although we agree you have Ulcerative Colitis, we do not feel your diarrhea is severe or frequent enough to make you unable to work" Whaaat? I'd like to see them try to stay hired with all I've got going on!
 
What I think happens first, is that some lower eschelon worker looks over the first application to see if you meet the specified criteria on his list, no variables; you can either walk or not, that kind of thing...... 85-90% people are denied at that stage!
 
Then if you persevere and reapply for Reconsideration, I bet they all roll their eyes when they see you did not give up and just go away, so now they have extra work.  At that point,somebody has the job of collecting info from your doctors. But what that means is they only accept a copy of your records, they send to the dr office. My docs are all disgusted that they are not allowed to give their opinions and explanations of how those findings at the office visit actually affect the patient's daily life.  Then eventually, an analyst... supposedly a doctor, gets assigned to your case and makes his decision.  Then, a panel reviews it... I can only wonder if they are doctors, and if so, how long has it been since they have routinely witnessed the daily effects of symptoms... and geesh, don't any of these people have relatives they love or friends who are struggling with disabilities yet get denied?
 
Linda, read my post, I've listed the steps I've been through, to help prepare K. 
Waddie replied after mine that she did all I did and it took her 2 years!
 
I can't wait that long! Since age 16, I paid into disability. After losing a job in my twenties for being "sicker than many patients" (too many lengthy hospitalizations, medical leaves, sick days), I only worked parttime, but they still took out for it. I need this check, which, by the way, is instead of SS that I can't get for 7 more years. I need it for rent after we lose our home and are kicked out. What are we going to do?
 
I do like Waddie's advice about getting a letter from my doctors. I'm going to ask my rheumatologist, gastroenterologist, podiatrist. No point with cardiologist or General P. as I'm stabilized with meds for the issues they attend to. I'll bring the letters to my Hearing before the Judge... whenever that will happen.
 
OK, I'm down off my soapbox. That's as much as I understand, or at least, think I understand about the process and who "they" are.
 
PS... K, dear, I'm sorry I've taken over your post. I'm so frustrated, I could spit nails!
CathyMarie 
I, too, got denied.  I was practically bed ridden and couldn't squeeze toothpaste.  I waited a over a year to apply for disability, b/c I kept thinking I was going to get better.  Eventually I was diagnosed w/ RA.  A year and half after symptoms began.
 
After denial I got a lawyer and am currently in appeal process.  A few months after I started Enbrel shots I started feeling better.  I worked with physical and occupational therapy for over 3 months last year and this helped quite a bit.  Before, I was unable to make a fist and now I can.
 
With Enbrel and PT I was able to start work about 5 weeks ago after being unemployed for over 3 years.  I was advised by my lawyer that filing for a 'closed period' is my best chance at getting disability.  This means they say that I was unable to work for a specific period of time, but now I can so that it is not 'unlimited' which is harder to get.
 
I know going back to work has been SO HARD.  My pain has increased quite a bit and I've developed more complications, partly from moving up north and being exposed to bitter cold temps.  Also, I moved out from my parents and on my own, which has made it even more difficult.  But I am trying to make this work.
 
I don't know your situation, but I wanted to let you know about that option.
 
Nori
After I filled out the papers,  2 months later I had a check. the doctors said they never seen anyone go down like I did.  my feet droped my hands wouldn't break bread or open adoor.my doctor toldme to get a lawer and sign up, they worked togatherand got me on had to go into their office once, lady had to fill out the pappers, I couldn't, got a letter few weeks later that I had been approve.  they put me in hospital and put predisone thur vains and went home on high dose. wore braces for a while and got back up on my feet and got a job.WHAT EVER YOU DO, IF YOU GET IT DON'T DO ANY KIND OF WORK,  THAT ENDED MY SS So 2 years later when I got back down, they turned me down, I had a fight them all the way.  Got same doctor and lawer  and started over, 1st. time turned down, had to go to there doctor had to appeal which was turned down, tried again and got a letter to go to court. that was the easest part, he was very nice and approve me after tlking to me.  You need to talk to your doctor and see if he'll get involed  with the lawer.  most people that I know got approved on 3rd. try.  I'm the only one I know who got it the 1st. time.

but if you do find medicine that works and gives you quality of life, why wouldn't you want to go back to work?  even if you are on ss disability, i would think the goal would be to get better and get back to work if you can.  not avoid work just in case you get worse again.

nori
nori: i loved working, thats why I went back, I don't care for disable.  RA is funny some never get better and most people hurt and swell more when they  work. It hurts, the best of meds can stops working at times.  you don't think as fast when you have drugs in you.   alot of jobs are unsafe for you. and the more you work the harder it is for you to have to prove that you can't, and before you know it your old and going to wish you had aken better care of yourself.
When I applied for disability, I picked my very worst day and gave graphic details of what this miserable disease had stolen from me. From "rushing" to the bathroom and not quite making to not being able to talk to my Mom on the phone for more than 5 minutes because of the screaming pain in my hands and arms. I ended up sending back about 12 extra sheets of paper just to try to make them understand what it was like to live my life. It took me about 2 weeks to write all that because I couldn't write for very long periods. I also told them that all their paperwork was making my hands flare up!

I was extremely lucky, I was approved in 3 months, without a lawyer. I think that when they saw all the papers I was sending back and all the work I created for them, they approved me just so they wouldn't have to read anymore from me!

Maybe it was that or what my doc wrote, I don't know. I hope you all will be approved and I wish you all the best of luck. Don't give up. Here's the addy for Social Security http://www.ssa.gov It has lots of info, like the trial work periods where you can earn up to X amount of dollars a month without losing your benefits. You could have also applied online. It will basically tell you everything you've wondered about disability and they have an extensive FAQ if they don't already cover what you want to know.

Another thing, check to see if your doc will sign the paper for a handicap parking permit. Check with the people at your driver's licensing place to see who has the forms. You might not have to use it everytime you go somewhere but it sure is handy to have on hand if you do need it.

Auntie... I do have a handicapped parking permit. I've also been ordered to use a cane and a scooter in stores (which I rarely go to). My RD figured out that the reason I've started having episodes of falling in my home is because I don't use the cane in the house. I also submitted pages of description of the limitations in my daily life, that took me a week to write.  I was afraid that turned them off or they just ignored the whole thing.  I'll be 60 on my next birthday, so that should make them happy.

Any other ideas?
CathyMarie
it seems those that get approved for ss disability have the support of their doctors.  i have not.  my doctors don't believe in ss disability for RA.  Even when i couldn't squeeze toothpaste or could barely walk.  before i was on ebrel or had PT which has made a big difference for me.  here's the irony.  my doctor was telling me i was fine then later prescribed enbrel.  if i was so fine, why bother prescribing a drug that has potential risks?  i have had bad luck w/ docs.  the first doctor said i had a less than 1% chance of having RA when I said i thought that was what i had.  gee guess what i was diagnosed with over 1 1/2 years later??
as a result of such a late diagnosis i have permanent swelling on some of my knuckles and permanent damage that could have been avoided with aggressive treatment.  i was in so much pain and no one would listen despite rheumatoid factor, ana antibodies, sed rate weak positive ccp antibodies, etc.  but i guess i'm off topic now....
long drawn out detailed day of your day is kinda how I went. I was not able to write much in one sitting, but I did write in detail the most bothersome things I had trouble with and how my husband had to pre-do & open everything before he left for work. I believe I even complained to them about the ole tampon monthly fiasco LOL! I had a guy caseworker hehehehee! Tooo funny, tooo funny. I did not know it was a guy until he kept calling me to schedule dr appts.
Another note on getting disability; make sure you make copies of EVERYTHING you send in to them.

I was told by the SS office their policy was to deny, deny and one more time, deny.  The lady told me my job was to appeal, and continue to do so until I came before a judge and panel.  She is the one who told me to get letters from every doctor I was seeing, so I got them from everyone.  My PCP told of past issues and RA related complications, my Cardiologist told of past issues and potential problems and so on.

Every little bit helps and the more they have to read the better.  I also kept a daily log of my RA issues.  I hope this all helps and good luck to everyone in this battle!

Copyright ArthritisInsight.com