Alternative health is nothing more than a giant scam to separate the scientifically naive from their money. The best and simplest example of this phenomenon is the use of herbs and supplements.
Devotees of alternative health like to pretend that herbs and supplements are better because they are "natural," because they are pure, and because they are not produced by Big Pharma. Nothing could be further from the truth.
First, "natural" is hardly synonymous with beneficial or even harmless. Earthquake, hurricanes and lightening strikes are all "natural" and quite harmful. More to the point, some of the most toxic substances known to man, like the paralytic poisons tetradotoxin and curare, are natural animal and plant products. Anyone who wonders whether "natural" equals beneficial need only contemplate tobacco, opium and cocaine.
Second, even if the active ingredient of an herb or supplement is harmless, it is mixed with contaminants in its natural state. As MSNBC explains:
Lead in ginkgo pills. Arsenic in herbals. Bugs in a baby's colic and teething syrup. Toxic metals and parasites are part of nature, and all of these have been found in "natural" products and dietary supplements in recent years.The risks are not simply theoretical:
Millions of Americans take vitamin, herbal or other dietary supplements. Annual sales exceed billion, and more than 40,000 products are on the market. Tens of thousands of supplement-related health problems are handled by U.S. poison control centers each year, according to a report in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2002.Because of vigorous lobbying efforts by supplement manufacturers, herbs and supplements are exempted from the rules that apply to medication. Therefore, there is no way for a consumer to be sure that a given herb or supplement contains any active ingredient, or contains too much or too little of the active ingredient. There is no testing to be sure that harmful contaminants are not present. Manufacturers simply grind up leaves and sell them to gullible people, and neither the manufacturers nor the consumers have any idea what's in them.
Until last year, supplement makers were not required to report problems to the FDA, and even now they must report only serious ones. The agency estimates that more than 50,000 safety problems a year are related to supplement use.
Alternative health is nothing more
than a giant scam to separate the scientifically naive from their money.
The best and simplest example of this phenomenon is the use of herbs
and supplements.
Devotees of alternative health like to pretend
that herbs and supplements are better because they are "natural,"
because they are pure, and because they are not produced by Big Pharma.
Nothing could be further from the truth.
First, "natural" is
hardly synonymous with beneficial or even harmless. Earthquake,
hurricanes and lightening strikes are all "natural" and quite harmful.
More to the point, some of the most toxic substances known to man, like
the paralytic poisons tetradotoxin and curare, are natural animal and
plant products. Anyone who wonders whether "natural" equals beneficial
need only contemplate tobacco, opium and cocaine.
Second, even if
the active ingredient of an herb or supplement is harmless, it is mixed
with contaminants in its natural state. As MSNBC explains:
Lead in ginkgo pills. Arsenic in herbals. Bugs in a baby's colic and teething syrup. Toxic metals and parasites are part of nature, and all of these have been found in "natural" products and dietary supplements in recent years.The risks are not simply theoretical:
Millions of Americans take vitamin, herbal or other dietary supplements. Annual sales exceed billion, and more than 40,000 products are on the market. Tens of thousands of supplement-related health problems are handled by U.S. poison control centers each year, according to a report in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2002.Because of vigorous lobbying efforts by supplement manufacturers, herbs and supplements are exempted from the rules that apply to medication. Therefore, there is no way for a consumer to be sure that a given herb or supplement contains any active ingredient, or contains too much or too little of the active ingredient. There is no testing to be sure that harmful contaminants are not present. Manufacturers simply grind up leaves and sell them to gullible people, and neither the manufacturers nor the consumers have any idea what's in them.
Until last year, supplement makers were not required to report problems to the FDA, and even now they must report only serious ones. The agency estimates that more than 50,000 safety problems a year are related to supplement use.